Is the CBA (ASX:CBA) share price a buy after its $212 million FY23 profit hit?

The Commonwealth Bank of Australia (ASX:CBA) share price has seen plenty of ups and downs over the past six months. Is it a buy?

You’re reading a free article on Rask. Join 4,000+ Australians who get our expert advice, tools, exclusive research and investment recommendations. Get your 30-day trial for $1! Learn more

The Commonwealth Bank of Australia (ASX: CBA) share price has seen plenty of ups and downs over the past six months. Is it a buy?

FY23 update

The bank has announced today an update about its FY23 financial result that will include notable items that are going to be included within operating expenses in the second half of FY23.

It comes at a total cost of $212 million, and these provisions are pre-tax.

CBA didn’t outline how the provisions were apportioned between each part, but some of the costs were associated with Bankwest, including the transition of business banking to CBA, and changes in the group’s operating model.

The rest of the provision related to the one-off levy for the Compensation Scheme of Last Resort after approval by the Australian Parliament in June 2023.

CBA said that it is going to exclude these items from its underlying operating expenses measure, and present operating expenses both on an underlying and headline basis.

Is the CBA share price a buy?

I understand why CBA has said these expenditure items are separate to its underlying expenses, but one-offs seem to happen so regularly for the large banks that it seems investors should just regularly expect a profit hit.

To me, CBA is one of the highest quality banks on the ASX, with Macquarie Group Ltd 

(ASX: MQG) being one of the best as well.

CBA trades at such a high valuation, referring to its price/earnings ratio (p/e ratio), that it doesn’t seem like good value right now. I’m concerned about the potential of there being a wave of arrears of borrowers can’t handle the shift to the higher interest rate environment.

How can CBA grow profit at a good pace in that environment? I don’t believe competition will ever get back to how it was a decade ago, so I don’t see how CBA can outperform over the long-term with it already commanding such a large market share.

Live webinar (with Q&A)

Earnings Season Whiplash
Why prices jump and crash, and how to think clearly when results hit

  • Presented by Owen Rask & Leigh Gant
  • Monday, 16 February   | 7pm AEDT 
At the time of publishing, Jaz does not have a financial or commercial interest in any of the companies mentioned.

A $50,000 per year passive income special report

Join more 50,000 Australian investors who read our weekly investing newsletter and we’ll send you our passive income investing report right now.

How can Rask help you?

About Rask

Learn more about us, our your community and our mission.

Rask investing philosophy

Nearly 15 years later.
It's still a work in progress.

Online investment community

You won't find our investment community on Facebook or Reddit because it's secure, free and available now.

Join 250,000+ podcast listeners

250,000 investors tune into the Rask podcasts every month. Find out why.

Find a financial planner

Australia's financial experts. At your doorstep.

Free finance courses

35,000 students have enrolled in free Rask courses. We're on a mission to 100,000.

Subscribe to Rask's free investor newsletter

53,000 Australian investors subscribe to our Sunday newsletter... and love it! It's free.

$50 million invested

We manage almost $50 million on behalf of Aussies. Discover how you can invest with us.

Build a better financial future, one Sunday at a time

Join over 50,000 savvy Australians receiving Rask’s free weekly email packed with investing insights, personal finance education, and the global stories that can shape your money decisions.


Because breaking down the barriers to finance is how more people learn to invest, build wealth and live life on their terms.

Download the ETF investing mini-series
checklist to follow along

We've created a free resource just for you: a simple editable checklist designed to accompany the podcast series that helps you apply what you learn as you go.

By downloading, you agree to receive emails from us. You can unsubscribe anytime.

Subscribe to Rask's free investor newsletter

Kick off your week with our pick of podcasts, courses and investing resources to keep your finger on the Rask pulse!

Here you go: A $50,000 per year passive income special report

Join more 50,000 Australian investors who read our weekly investing newsletter and we’ll send you our passive income investing report right now.

Simply enter your email address and we’ll send it to you. No tricks. Unsubscribe anytime.

Read our TermsFinancial Services GuidePrivacy Policy. We’ll never sell your email address. Our company is Australian owned.